It's spring of 2010 and Matt Ryan is now running a private detective agency with the help of his lapsed Mormon assistant, Carrie Zimmerman. The work is steady but tedious. That is, until another lapsed Mormon, Annie Christiansen, hires Ryan to investigate her estranged husband's murder. As a mutual attraction between the Ryan and his new client smolders, he is drawn back into the LDS community, this time in pursuit of a serial killer. The chase takes Ryan and Carrie to Utah where they encounter a web of patriarchs and prophets, blood oaths and second anointings, along with other ghosts that conjure up from the Mormons' colorful past.